
Google Search, the budget line agencies have rarely had to defend, is now being asked to justify itself. Media buyers interviewed by Digiday for a report published on 2 November said clients are questioning between 10% and 30% of their Google Search spend, as AI Overviews and AI Mode change how people click and make returns harder to read.
The scrutiny lands on the channel B2B software companies rely on most to capture buyers who are already in market. Google’s own third-quarter results showed Search revenue growth slowing while query volume grew at its fastest pace in five years, and its help documentation confirms advertisers cannot see how their ads perform inside AI Overviews. Few agencies describe walking away from Search. The dispute is over how much of the revenue it claims it actually causes.
Advertisers are reviewing far more of their Google Search budgets than they are cutting, and the figures come from individual agency leaders rather than a market survey. Lindsay Marty, founder of Above the Bar Marketing, told Digiday that clients generally question 10–20% of their Google budget when performance comes up, and some are open to moving part of it to Meta or Local Services Ads. Bryce Hamlin, vice-president of data intelligence at Power Digital, estimated that 10–30% of Google Search budgets were being reallocated. Farhad Divecha, group CEO of Accuracast, put the questioned share among his clients at about 10%, and said it could reach 20–30% quickly around Black Friday and Cyber Monday.
Other buyers described a narrower shift. Victor Batista, global search lead at Jellyfish, said clients were not cutting Google spend in a targeted way and that diversification was “generally contained within the Google ecosystem”, with budget moving from keyword campaigns into AI Max, Performance Max, YouTube and Demand Gen. Michelle Merklin, vice-president of search at Tinuiti, said some clients were trimming inefficient competitor-keyword campaigns, but most were adding budget elsewhere rather than taking it from Search.
Primer’s State of B2B Paid Advertising 2026, published on 11 November, offers the clearest B2B-specific view. Across 379 B2B advertisers over the 12 months to August 2026, it found Google’s median cost per click up about 11% and platform-reported cost per conversion up about 27%. Among advertisers tracked in both December–February and June–August, Google’s average share of paid budget fell from 43.6% to 40.9%, while Meta’s rose from 20.8% to 24.9%. LinkedIn’s share was roughly flat. The figures carry caveats: Primer sells audience-targeting products, the share data covers Google advertising as a whole rather than Search alone, and the report does not say how many advertisers sit in the comparison group.
Google Search is getting more expensive while click growth slows, though the data does not show that AI Overviews are the cause. Tinuiti’s Q3 2026 Digital Ads Benchmark Report, drawn from the agency’s own client programmes, found Google Search cost per click rose 4% year on year in the third quarter after averaging no growth over the previous four quarters. Click growth slowed by four points to 9%, and growth in text-ad clicks fell to 4%. Tinuiti tied the price rise to structural changes in who is bidding, including large ecommerce platforms expanding their presence in Google’s auctions.
Seer Interactive’s tracking of 53 brands and 5.47 million queries between January 2025 and February 2026 shows how differently paid listings perform when an AI Overview appears. Paid click-through rate on queries with an Overview ran between 12.9% and 16.2% across the period, against 17.6% to 26% on queries without one. The gap narrowed from 11.3 points in January 2025 to 5.6 points in February 2026, largely because paid click-through on queries without an Overview fell. Seer describes the study as directional and says it cannot claim causation.
Google’s results show the same pressure at the revenue line. Alphabet reported Search and other revenue of $63.35bn for the third quarter, up 12% year on year against 17% growth in the second. On the earnings call, chief business officer Philipp Schindler said the strong growth in AI Mode queries had an impact “because of the lower monetization we were seeing in AI Mode”, and said Google was scaling ads in AI Overviews and AI Mode to more users and queries. The Marketing Helm reported at the time that Google said AI Mode earns less as growth slowed.
Advertisers cannot isolate the effect for themselves. Google’s Ads help documentation states that it does not currently offer segmented reporting when ads show in AI Overviews, and that advertisers can neither target nor opt out of the placement. Text and Shopping ads from Search, Shopping and Performance Max campaigns are all eligible, so any change in performance arrives folded into the campaign total.
Some agencies are moving from attribution reports to experiments that measure what Search adds on top of demand that already exists. Power Digital’s Hamlin said media-mix modelling and geo-testing had shown more impact from upper-funnel media and less from Search than attribution suggested, and those results are shaping his clients’ budget decisions.
Google’s own measurement guidance assigns each method a different job. It describes marketing mix models as suited to overall budget distribution across channels, attribution as a tool for day-to-day optimisation, and incrementality testing as the way to measure the incremental return of a specific channel or format. Its Conversion Lift experiments run in two forms: one splits users into exposed and control groups, and the other compares matched geographic areas without relying on cookies.
For B2B software companies, the outcome being tested matters as much as the method. Platform-reported conversions in a long sales cycle are usually form fills, and Marty’s clients are already looking past the click to lead quality and revenue. A test that ties Search exposure to qualified opportunities, pipeline and closed revenue, imported back from the CRM, gives a budget decision far firmer ground than cost per lead.
Agencies also disagree on where Search fits. Mark Byrne, director of paid media at Brave Bison, frames Google as strong at capturing existing demand, with paid social and YouTube building it earlier. Merklin said Tinuiti clients are funding mid- and upper-funnel activity partly to grow branded search volume. Casey Sheehan of RPA argued that paid Search is becoming more important as organic traffic comes under pressure, and Valerie Dorer of Wpromote recommended pairing it with a strong presence in organic AI citations.
Google’s help page on ads in AI Overviews says segmented reporting is not currently offered, and gives no timeline for adding it.